* = deceased
| 1910 W.H. Carter* |
1952 Garland Stickler* |
1987 John Lefever |
| 1911 Henry Shoemaker* |
1953 James C. Gallagher* |
1988 Ira "Bill" Webber |
| 1912 Hugo Logan* |
1954 Scott Holderbaum* |
1989 Michael Rush |
| 1913 B.F. Cooper* |
1955 David Spence* |
1990 Paul R. Anders* |
| 1914 Alexander Knisely* |
1956 Stuart Smith* |
1991 James Rohrbach* |
| 1915 J.W. Baker* |
1957 Robert E. Gates * |
1992 Dr. Clark Waterfall* |
| 1916 Eph K. Strong* |
1958 Wm. C. Thomson, Jr.* |
1993 Arthur (Dee) Trier |
| 1917 Frank L. Myers* |
1959 David Walter, Jr.* |
1994 Eugene Heckman* |
| 1918 Henry E. Romey* |
1960 A.K. Strouse* |
1995 Larry Whetstone |
| 1919 Bery Clugston* |
1961 Robert E. Erdmann* |
1996 Wilbur Waterson * |
| 1920 Ernest Cotterly* |
1962 Arthur Trier, Jr.* |
1997 Patricia McNagny* |
| 1921 Spurgeon Markley* |
1963 Willard Phillips* |
1998 Gregory Fahl |
| 1922 Arthur Hancock* |
1964 H.A. Morris* |
1999 Scott Gates |
| 1923 Jacob Flox* |
1965 Ira C. Webber* |
2000 James Fleck |
| 1924 Benton J. Bloom* |
1966 Jack V. Squires* |
2001 Tim Bloom |
| 1925 Ralph F. Gates* |
1967 Benton E. Gates, Jr. * |
2002 Richard Buchanan |
| 1926 Patrick Maloney* |
1968 Jack Gates* |
2003 William Overdeer |
| 1927 Milton M. Lorber* |
1969 Edgar Strouse, Jr.* |
2004 James Nelson |
| 1928 Frank M. Northam* |
1970 Robert Williams* |
2005 Laura Lefever |
| 1929 G. Fred Yontz* |
1971 Gerald Redman* |
2006 Mike Redman |
| 1930 Lee Daniel* |
1972 Joseph R. Roe* |
2007 Taron Smith |
| 1931 Ernest Cotterly* |
1973 Carl Anderson* |
2008 Fritz Martin* |
| 1932 J. A. De Money* |
1974 Paul Redman* |
2009 Tom Drew* |
| 1933 Guy Mullendore* |
1975 Robert DeMoney* |
2010 Jim Brock |
| 1934 Benton E. Gates* |
1976 Carl Arnston* |
2011 Jacie Worrick |
| 1939 Garland Mullendore* |
1977 Keith H. Dowell * |
2012 Toban Chapman |
| 1940 William C. Thomson* |
1978 Richard W. Gates* |
2013 Glenn Snapp* |
| 1941 Virgil Heinley* |
1979 Vernon Trier * |
2014 Kay Fleck |
| 1942-1945 Paul J. Morsches* |
1980 C. Taron Smith |
2015 John Meier |
| 1946 Edward C. Binder* |
1981 Harold H. Wheeler* |
2016 Don Armstrong |
| 1947 Austin C. Overdeer* |
1982 Gerald E. Meyer* |
2017 Gene Smith |
| 1948 John Whiteleather, Sr. * |
1983 Robert E. Phillips* |
2018 Ralph Bailey* |
| 1949 James A. Brown* |
1984 Jay Crawford* |
2019 Michael Schrader |
| 1950 Leland Williams* |
1985 Robert Hollingsworth* |
2020 Marcia McNagny |
| 1951 Benton W. Bloom* |
1986 Robert L. Walker* |
2021 Robin Wright |
| 2022 Jeff Walker |